top of page

Involved in a car collision or a fall? Here are thoughts for actions on the scene:

Writer: Eric Ganci, Esq.
Eric Ganci, Esq.
Aug 30
5 min read

After an incident happens: what you gather in the first hours can decide your case

Most people never plan for the moment an incident happens. One second you’re driving to work or walking through a store, and the next second everything changes.


And in that moment, you may not be thinking about evidence. You’re probably dealing with medical professional or just in shock.


I get it. But here’s the reality of how these cases work: the proof of what happened starts disappearing almost immediately. Cars get repaired. Floors get mopped.


Witnesses walk away. Memories fade. What you can gather in the first minutes, hours, and days after an incident is often the difference between a case that can be proven and a case that turns into your word against theirs.


So let’s talk about three things you may want to consider immediately after an incident like a car collision or a fall from a dangerous floor at a store: take pictures, get medical help, and be careful about who you talk to.


1. Take pictures. Then take more pictures.

You are carrying a camera in your pocket. Use it.


There is no such thing as too many photos. Nobody has ever called me and said “I wish

I had taken fewer pictures.” But I have had plenty of conversations that go the other way.


If you’re in a car collision:


Take pictures of:

  • All the body damage. Not just your car. Every vehicle involved. Get wide shots showing the whole vehicle, and then get in close on the damaged areas. Damage photos tell a story about the force of the impact, the angle of the impact, and where each car was hit. That matters later when someone tries to argue this was a “minor” collision.

  • Insurance information and identifying information. Photograph the other driver’s insurance card, their driver’s license, and the license plate of every vehicle involved. Don’t rely on someone writing information down for you, and don’t rely on your own memory. Get an image of the actual document. If the driver’s name on the license doesn’t match the name on the insurance card or the registration, that is something you want captured, because that can matter a great deal down the road.

  • The scene itself. Traffic signals, stop signs, skid marks, debris in the roadway, the position of the vehicles before they get moved, the weather, the lighting. You may want to take a short video and slowly turn in a full circle. That’s often a good way to preserve a scene.

  • Witnesses. If someone stopped who was not directly involved in the collision, get their name and phone number, and if they’re willing, photograph their identifying information too. Independent witnesses can be important in these cases, precisely because they have no stake in the outcome. And they are the single easiest piece of evidence to lose. Once that person drives away without you getting their contact information, they may be gone for good.


If it’s a dangerous condition on a floor:


Falling incidents from dangerous floors may turn on questions like: what was on the floor, and how long had it been there?


So if you’re able to, photograph:

  • The condition of the floor itself, up close and from a distance.

  • Whatever was actually on the floor. Was it liquid? What color? Was there a footprint or a cart track through it? Was it dirty, or had it been walked through? Those details speak to how long the substance had been sitting there before you came along.

  • The surrounding area. Is there a leaking cooler nearby? A spill that trails back to a source? A dripping ceiling? Missing warning cones? Are there floor mats, and are they where they should be? Is there a camera on the ceiling pointed at that spot?

  • The lighting, and anything blocking the view of the hazard.


One caveat that matters: your safety comes first. If you’re seriously hurt, don’t crawl around taking photos. Ask someone with you to do it, or ask the store to preserve their video. Do what you can.


2. Get medical help as close in time to the incident as possible

This is the point I wish more people understood before they need it.

After a traumatic event, your body dumps adrenaline. You’re in shock. You may not be, in that moment, a reliable judge of how badly you’ve been hurt. I have talked with many people who told the officer at the scene they were “fine,” went home, and then woke up the next morning barely able to turn their head or get out of bed. That is not unusual. That is normal.


So you often need an outside medical professional to look at what your body has actually been through. A doctor is trained to find things you can’t feel yet, and to spot the injuries that don’t announce themselves right away. Head injuries, in particular, do not always look like anything at all on day one.


There’s a second reason too, and I’ll be direct about it: getting evaluated creates a paper trail.


Every visit, every note, every imaging study is a data point about how your body was doing at a specific moment in time. Those data points connect the incident to your injuries, and they show how you progressed, or didn’t. When there’s a gap — days or weeks where you saw nobody and told nobody — you can be sure that gap will be pointed at later, and the argument will be that you must not have been hurt very badly.


Get checked out. Be honest and complete about every part of your body that hurts, not just the worst one. And follow up.


3. Be careful before you talk to any insurance carrier or adjuster

Insurance carriers often want to talk with you as soon as possible after an incident. Sometimes within hours. That timing is not an accident.


They are gathering information about what can and cannot be proven, and those conversations are frequently recorded and transcribed. Which means what you say can later become evidence in your case, and it can work for you or against you.


Two things are usually going on. First, the carrier is looking for any way to argue that their insured was not at fault, or not entirely at fault, for causing the collision. Second, they’re trying to understand and shape what your claimed injuries are.


On that second point, the questions can be tricky by design. “How are you doing today?” is a friendly question in normal life. In a recorded statement taken three days after a crash, “I’m doing okay, thanks” can be read back to a jury two years later as your own words about how you were feeling.


You are also, in those first days, being asked to describe injuries before you or your doctors fully know what they are. It is very hard to accurately answer questions about a body you haven’t had evaluated yet.


So before you give any statement to an insurance carrier or adjuster, it can be important to talk with a lawyer first. That’s not about hiding anything. It’s about making sure the record that gets created is accurate.


The short version


Hopefully, you never find yourself in need of this information, but if it were to happen, it can be crucial that you understand what steps can be very important.


Photograph everything. Get medical attention quickly and honestly. And think carefully before you give a recorded statement.


Evidence may be easiest to gather at the beginning and hardest to recreate at the end. The people who protect themselves best are the ones who take those first steps early.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page